M&C Web Exclusive: The Short-Course Advantage
Planners can significantly cut the time and cost of a golf event by booking a nine-hole course.
"For corporate golf outings, unless you're dealing with really avid golfers, the nine-hole aspect just makes it much easier for people to give up a smaller portion of time," says Brent DeRaad, executive vice president and head of the golf advisory committee for the Scottsdale (Ariz.) Convention & Visitors Bureau.
Golf can be worked into an event even without making it a tournament. "We're coming up with creative ways to incorporate golf that might be more cost-effective and also don't take five to six hours of a three-day program," says Charles Kingsbaker, regional director of sales and marketing for Scottsdale-based Troon Golf.
A nine-hole putting contest with hors d'oeuvres and a bar is one alternative, with the added benefit that both golfers and nongolfers can participate.
"Rather than a $300-per-person, all-inclusive golf package that takes five hours," Kingsbaker says, "you can still include golf and spend only $50 to $75 per person."
Eric Redd isn't nervous anymore. "Last January, I was scared to death of what might happen," admits the PGA professional and president of Eric Redd's Golf Event Co., based in Palm Desert, Calif., "and now we're actually up for the year. We've seen people spend less, but we haven't seen many events fizzle out because of the economy."
Lori Burton, an incentives manager for Woodstock, Ga.-based GamePlan Financial, supports this assessment. Burton, who plans three golf-focused incentive trips every year, says she has not had to cancel any events. However, "we have been directed to scale back," she says. "We're not doing international events now."
For planners, some softness in the market means golf courses feeling the pinch might be more willing to negotiate to secure group business. In fact, courses might be even more flexible than hotels. As Redd puts it, "The rap to the hotels is, 'Have you guys seen the economy? What's up with this room rate?' And they will give you the song and dance, because they're trying as hard as they can to hold the rate."
Not so for golf courses, which "have been very accommodating and tried very hard to reduce their rates to assist," Redd says. "They've been lenient with their cancellation and attrition clauses, and willing to negotiate up to some point."
What follows are front-line reports from key players in the group-golf business, along with pointers for those with golf events to arrange.
Who you know
"The relationship between meeting planner and golf course is even more important now," says Charles Kingsbaker, regional director of sales and marketing for Scottsdale, Ariz.-based Troon Golf, which manages 200 courses worldwide. "The planner's clients are always looking for more bang for their buck. If the planner has confidence in the course, there is more trust there from the standpoint of, 'I know I'm going to take my business to this golf provider.'
"The golf courses also realize that if they provide a real high-quality experience, their relationship with the planner is going to improve," Kingsbaker adds.
The overall hope is, once the economy pulls out of its decline, planners will remember which golf courses went the extra mile when times were rough -- and repay them with future business.
Money back
In Walt Disney World, "We definitely have seen people starting to back off" from golf events, says Steve Harker, manager of golf sales and performance for Lake Buena Vista, Fla.-based Disney Group Golf Sales. "We haven't had any of our golf events cancel yet, but we are expecting it could happen."
In response, Disney is dangling a few incentives to try to keep that business on the books. "Some courses will provide some golf and rooms to groups that bring a certain number of people," Harker notes. "A couple offer a straight 5 percent of the total golf bill back to the meeting planner either as a payment or as credit."
Smart Strategies
Some expert advice for selecting a golf course on a limited budget:
1. Engage competition. Shop around, and then go
back to your favorite courses and ask if they'll match others' offers.
"Say, 'Here's what the course down the street does... Can you do
this?' " suggests Steve Harker, manager of golf sales and performance
for Lake Buena Vista, Fla.-based Disney Group Golf Sales. "That's a
good way to get concessions from the course you want."
2. Seek out remodels.
Lori Burton, incentive manager for Woodstock, Ga.-based GamePlan
Financial, recalls, "One trip came up last-minute, and knowing that I
had a limited budget and limited time, I sought out resorts that were
coming out of remodels and needed people in the door."
3. Think big.
"The big conglomerates like American Golf or Troon are much more
willing to work with you than some individual courses," notes Fred
Greco, owner of Doylestown, Pa.-based Global Golf Events. "This is
because they have such a large portfolio, they need to have cash coming
in."
4. Check references. "One thing a planner should do
that we don't see: Ask for references," says Charles Kingsbaker,
regional director of sales and marketing for Scottsdale, Ariz.-based
Troon Golf. "It might not save you money, but you will be able to
determine whether or not a golf course honors its promises." -- H.R.S.
Packages and extras
Troon Golf's Kingsbaker believes meeting planners will be seeing more
value-added offerings. "A lot of the golf facilities are starting to
include, say, space for an off-site meeting or pre-event," he says.
"They might also throw in a keepsakes amenities package."
Watch for more package deals, too. "A lot of courses are trying to
package in food and beverage into the cost of tournaments," notes Brent
DeRaad, executive vice president and head of the golf advisory
committee for the Scottsdale Convention & Visitors Bureau. "And
courses will stage, at no cost, all the scoring, set-up and
administration."
For example, TPC Scottsdale, a Sonoran Desert golf course where the PGA
Tour's FBR Open is played, is willing to waive the shotgun fee,
tournament fee and prize fund.
If you want something else, just ask. Says DeRaad, "Planners certainly have a lot of leverage at this point."
Always negotiate
Many courses haven't established special enticements for groups, but
they're willing to discuss. That's certainly true in the Myrtle Beach,
S.C., area, says Steve Mays, senior director of marketing for Myrtle
Beach Golf Holiday, a nonprofit co-op for the local golf industry.
Offers are made on a case-by-case basis, he notes.
Other sources agree. "I'm always willing to help," says Robert Ames,
director of golf operations at Cinnamon Hill Golf Course, which is
associated with Jamaica's recently revamped Rose Hall Resort & Spa.
"If it means discounting my rates, then we would look at doing that."
Planner Lori Burton recently brought a golf incentive to Cinnamon Hill,
where she worked with Ames. "Rose Hall was really helpful," she says.
"We sat down, he asked me what my budget was, we went back and forth
probably twice -- and they were really willing to hit the number I
needed to hit."